Toulmin Award

Toulmin Award

The Toulmin Medal was created by Col. H.A. Toulmin, U.S. Army Air Corps, and first awarded in 1932. Two medals may be awarded annually—one to a Regular Member of SAME (including Life, Enlisted, Fully-Retired or Sustaining Member Representative) and one to a Young Member of SAME—based on quality of the article.

Eligibility

In order for an article to be eligible for consideration for the Toulmin Medal:

All authors of an individual article in The Military Engineer must be a member of SAME prior to publication of the article. In the case of multiple authors of an article, the lead author of the winning article will be awarded the Toulmin Medal.

Nomination Criteria

The published article must:

  1. Contribute to the knowledge of military engineering or national security; and
  2. Publicize and preserve the accomplishments of engineers in their missions throughout the world.
Nomination and Submission Process

No nominations are accepted for this medal. A committee selects based on the articles published in The Military Engineer in the prior year.

Evaluation Criteria:

Articles that are eligible for the Toulmin Medal and meet the nomination criteria will be evaluated by a panel of judges based on the overall quality of the article including writing style, and the use of strong examples and real-life scenarios, up-to-date facts, sound approaches to solving problems and, where applicable, concise information that addresses the impact of the method, technology or system to users in the years ahead.

Past Toulmin Medal Recipients
YearRecipient(s)Article
2025Nancy Balkus, P.E., SES, HQ U.S. Air Force; Ashley Sadorra, Idaho National LaboratoryMeeting Energy Challenges Through Nuclear Microreactors and Data Technologies
2024Daryl Haegley, GICSP, Department of the Air ForceDeveloping an Engineering Standard of Care for Cyber Safety
2023Henrik Dahl, COWI North America; Victor Tirado, P.E., GHDModernizing Dry Dock No. 1 at Naval Base San Diego
2022William Boudra, P.E., F.SAME, NAVFAC Guam Program Management OfficeBuilding an Operating Platform in the Western Pacific
2021JJ Tang; Michael Doiel; Matthew BirdDesigning a National Asset
2020RDML Dean VanderLey, P.E., USN; John J.C. Douglass, AICPModernizing Shipyards for the Fleet of the Future
2019Jon Schmidt, P.E., SECB, Burns & McDonnellEvolving Antiterrorism Standards for Buildings
2018Steven Miles, P.E., F.SAME, USACE Hydroelectric Design CenterCorps Power is Water Power
2017Rob McAtee, P.E., CEM, LEED AP, Mason & HangerDesigning for Energy Security in an Unsecure World
2016Lt. Col. Kevin Lovell, PMP, USA (Ret.)Delivering Value to the Nation
2015Maj. Erica Tortella, USAFMission Support to Mission Essential
2014Maj. Tobin Flinn, PMP, USAExpeditionary, Agile and Ready to Deploy
2013Col. Douglas P. Wise, P.E., CEM, GBE, USAF (Ret.)Energy Security: A National Roadmap
2012Lt. Col. John Buse, P.E., USAFR; Col. Joel Cross, PMP, USATransition to Diplomacy
2011Col. Jeffry Knippel, USAFTwo Models, One Mission
2010Col. Michael Hutchison, LEED AP, F.SAME, USAF (Ret.)
Honorable Mention: Col. Fred Wenger III, PMP, USMC (Ret.)
Advancing MILCON Transformation
2009Maj. Frank R. Hughes, P.E., USAF
Honorable Mention: Mr. Steven Ashton and Lt Col. Christian Knutson, USAF
Military Construction at Bagram Airfield
2008Christopher Day, P.E.Master Planning in the AOR
2007Larry D. Walker; Michael J. Roth, P.E.Stabilization Reconstruction; Overhead Protection
2006Maj. Phillip L. Landeros; Maj. Jared L. WareBridging the Tigris; Geospatial Intelligence and Engineers
2005Keith Kowadio, P.E.Time-Saving Lean Design
2004Col. Christopher J. Toomey; Capt. James S. DukeBuilding in Contingencies and in Combat; Value-Focused Energy Solutions
2003Marc S. Caspe, P.E.; Sgt. Robert WoodwardTerrorism & Energy Dissipating Systems; Spanning More than a River
2002Linda N. Allen; Col. Douglas D. Gransberg; Keith R. Molenaar; Diana L. PletzPartnering D-B Contracts; Recent Graduates: On the Job
2001Larry Woscyna; Lt. Scott WashburnKissimmee River Restoration; Old Light Station Sheds New Light
2000Dana Finney; Lt. David J. Palazzetti, USCGSmart Sensors at West Point; Maine Lights Program: Saving by Divestiture
1999John E. Peters; Lt. John P. Slaughter, USCGNew in Naples; Disasters and the Coast Guard
1998Lt. Cmdr. John W. Korka; Maj. Daniel J. WorthSeabees in Bosnia
1997Capt. Mark L. Gillem; Maj. Donald F. Archibald; Stephen W. HughesCreating Communities Not Compounds; Operation Joint Endeavor: Environmental Lessons
1996Maj. Peter Tabacchi; Dr. Paul F. Mlaker; Col. Bruce K. Howard; Paul ReddingRestoring Brcko Bridge; On-Target Remediation
1995Dr. Mark E. Zappi; Capt. Micheal BowenPeroxone POPS Groundwater; What’s Wrong with Mitigation Banks?
1994Capt. Palmer W. Roberts; Jennifer C. MettsNormandy: The Naval Story; Environmental Cleanup for Base Closure
1993Brig. Gen. Ralph V. Locurcio; Col. Frank R. Finch; Maj. Deborah L. Nykyforchyn; Mary L. HughesPiercing Winds Hit Hawaii; Aerospace Composites for Civil Engineers
1992Gordon S. Crighton; Capt. John E. BuseEurope’s Channel Tunnel; Engineer Warrior Day
1991Dr. Benjamin W. Remondi; C. Ernest Edgar IVArtificial Constellation: The Global Positioning System; 249th Engineers Storm the Desert
19901st Lt. Mark E. Austin; Rear Adm. G. Brian EstesA New Method of Runway Repair; Trident Base East-Completing the Construction Program
1989Dr. Jacques S. Gansler; Lauren KaslowChanges in the Defense Engineering/Business Environment for the 1990s; The DASE Co-op Program
1988*Graham Turbiville; Capt. Michael J. KaledaSoviet Engineers in Afghanistan; Building a Home for the B-1
1987Dr. Alexander G. TaricsEarthquake: Are We Ready?
1986Dr. Paul E. TorgersenThe Health of Engineering Education
1985George B. Korte, Jr.CADD’s Impact on NE Firms
1984Lt. Col. Andrew M. PerkinsOperation URGENT FURY; An Engineer’s View
1983Dr. Jacques S. GanslerIndustrial Preparedness: National Security in the Nuclear Age
1982Thomas H. SpencerThe NE’s Role in Mobilization
1981Dr. Hungdah ChiuA Rapprochement Between the Two Chinas?
1980James G. StanleyEnergy for Today and Tomorrow
1979Dr. Leland R. Johnson19th Century Engineering: The Davis Island Lock and Dam (Parts I & II)
1978Richard P. HowellUpgrading the Northeast Rail Corridor
1977Harry E. BovayGlobal Resources Outlook
1976Dr. Leland R. JohnsonSword, Shovel, and Compass
1975Brig. Gen. William Whipple, Jr.Water Supply and Energy Production in the Northeast
1974Brig. Gen. George A. LincolnEnergy Security
1973Dr. Leland R. Johnson19th Century Engineering
1972Maj. Gen. Richard H. GrovesThe AGNES Disaster
1971Maj. William B. Willard, Jr.The National Environmental Crisis-An Engineer’s View
1970Lt. Cmdr. Robert D. SmartMan in the Sea: An Ocean Engineering Resource
1969Walter J. TudorAntarctic Wharf In the Ice
1968Lt. Col. Maurice K. Kurtz, Jr.Nuclear Excavation Research
1967Brig. Gen. Harry G. Woodbury, Jr.Shipway between the Oceans
1966Lt. James C. ThomasThe Computer Story
1965Kenneth R. StunkelA Chronical of Mapping
1964Alfred R. GolzeCalifornia State Water Project
1963Col. Richard L. ClutterbuckMilitary Engineering as a Weapon in the Cold War
1962Brig. Gen. William R. WoodwardSpace Logistics from Earth to Mars
1961Capt. Charles J. MerdingerBridges through the Ages
1960Lt. Cmdr. J.C. LeDouxNuclear Power: Promise and Problems
1959Capt. Fred E. KravathNuclear Development in Continental Europe
1958Lt. Gen. R.A. WheelerClearing the Suez Canal
1957Cmdr. Charles J. MerdingerCanals through the Ages
1956Prof. Frank R. BarnettCracking the Thought Barrier
1955Lt. Gen. Leslie R. GrovesEducating America for the Atomic Age
1954Brig. Gen. John R. HardinThe Mississippi-Atchafalaya Diversion Problem
1953Cmdr. Palmer W. RobertsCold Weather Engineering
1952Cmdr. Charles J. MerdingerRoads through the Ages and Civil Engineering through the Ages
1951Lt. Col. Robert R. EllisThe Confederate Corps of Engineers
1950Lt. Col. David B. ParkerEngineers in Atomic Offense And Defense
1949Lt. Col. Stanley W. DziubanArtificial Flooding in Military Operations
1948Dr. Roger ShawAdam to Atom
1947Brig. Gen. Samuel D. Sturgis, Jr.Engineer Operations in the Leyte Campaign
1946Maj. Philip G. KruegerThree Articles on Operation Crossroads
1945Maj. Gen. Cecil R. MooreEngineer Supply in the Continental Invasion
1944Lt. Col. Walter C. CareySoil Engineering Practices for Military Engineers
1943Maj. Gen. Julian L SchleyPolicy of Preparedness
1942Lt. Col. Shelby A. McMillionStrategic Route to Alaska
1941Lt. Col. Paul W. ThompsonEngineers in Battle
1940Capt. Alfred D. StarbirdStrategic Canals
1939Col. R.T. WardEngineers in the First Army Maneuvers at Plattsburg
1938Maj. G.A. RoushStrategic & Critical Minerals
1937Maj. Elbridge ColbyJohn Churchill, Duke of Marlborough
1936Maj. B.T. ReynoldsItaly, Ethiopia, and World Affairs
1935Verne G. SandersSurvey Map Control for Los Angeles
1934Col. W. G. CaplesTransportation
1933Col. Thomas H. JacksonLeadership and Organization
1932Col. E.G. PaulesWith the Military Mission to Italy

* Second medal authorized in 1988 for young members.