Toulmin Award
The Toulmin Medal was created by Col. H.A. Toulmin, U.S. Army Air Corps, and first awarded in 1932. Two medals may be awarded annually—one to a Regular Member of SAME (including Life, Enlisted, Fully-Retired or Sustaining Member Representative) and one to a Young Member of SAME—based on quality of the article.
Eligibility
In order for an article to be eligible for consideration for the Toulmin Medal:
All authors of an individual article in The Military Engineer must be a member of SAME prior to publication of the article. In the case of multiple authors of an article, the lead author of the winning article will be awarded the Toulmin Medal.
Nomination Criteria
The published article must:
- Contribute to the knowledge of military engineering or national security; and
- Publicize and preserve the accomplishments of engineers in their missions throughout the world.
Nomination and Submission Process
No nominations are accepted for this medal. A committee selects based on the articles published in The Military Engineer in the prior year.
Evaluation Criteria:
Articles that are eligible for the Toulmin Medal and meet the nomination criteria will be evaluated by a panel of judges based on the overall quality of the article including writing style, and the use of strong examples and real-life scenarios, up-to-date facts, sound approaches to solving problems and, where applicable, concise information that addresses the impact of the method, technology or system to users in the years ahead.
| Year | Recipient(s) | Article |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Nancy Balkus, P.E., SES, HQ U.S. Air Force; Ashley Sadorra, Idaho National Laboratory | Meeting Energy Challenges Through Nuclear Microreactors and Data Technologies |
| 2024 | Daryl Haegley, GICSP, Department of the Air Force | Developing an Engineering Standard of Care for Cyber Safety |
| 2023 | Henrik Dahl, COWI North America; Victor Tirado, P.E., GHD | Modernizing Dry Dock No. 1 at Naval Base San Diego |
| 2022 | William Boudra, P.E., F.SAME, NAVFAC Guam Program Management Office | Building an Operating Platform in the Western Pacific |
| 2021 | JJ Tang; Michael Doiel; Matthew Bird | Designing a National Asset |
| 2020 | RDML Dean VanderLey, P.E., USN; John J.C. Douglass, AICP | Modernizing Shipyards for the Fleet of the Future |
| 2019 | Jon Schmidt, P.E., SECB, Burns & McDonnell | Evolving Antiterrorism Standards for Buildings |
| 2018 | Steven Miles, P.E., F.SAME, USACE Hydroelectric Design Center | Corps Power is Water Power |
| 2017 | Rob McAtee, P.E., CEM, LEED AP, Mason & Hanger | Designing for Energy Security in an Unsecure World |
| 2016 | Lt. Col. Kevin Lovell, PMP, USA (Ret.) | Delivering Value to the Nation |
| 2015 | Maj. Erica Tortella, USAF | Mission Support to Mission Essential |
| 2014 | Maj. Tobin Flinn, PMP, USA | Expeditionary, Agile and Ready to Deploy |
| 2013 | Col. Douglas P. Wise, P.E., CEM, GBE, USAF (Ret.) | Energy Security: A National Roadmap |
| 2012 | Lt. Col. John Buse, P.E., USAFR; Col. Joel Cross, PMP, USA | Transition to Diplomacy |
| 2011 | Col. Jeffry Knippel, USAF | Two Models, One Mission |
| 2010 | Col. Michael Hutchison, LEED AP, F.SAME, USAF (Ret.) Honorable Mention: Col. Fred Wenger III, PMP, USMC (Ret.) | Advancing MILCON Transformation |
| 2009 | Maj. Frank R. Hughes, P.E., USAF Honorable Mention: Mr. Steven Ashton and Lt Col. Christian Knutson, USAF | Military Construction at Bagram Airfield |
| 2008 | Christopher Day, P.E. | Master Planning in the AOR |
| 2007 | Larry D. Walker; Michael J. Roth, P.E. | Stabilization Reconstruction; Overhead Protection |
| 2006 | Maj. Phillip L. Landeros; Maj. Jared L. Ware | Bridging the Tigris; Geospatial Intelligence and Engineers |
| 2005 | Keith Kowadio, P.E. | Time-Saving Lean Design |
| 2004 | Col. Christopher J. Toomey; Capt. James S. Duke | Building in Contingencies and in Combat; Value-Focused Energy Solutions |
| 2003 | Marc S. Caspe, P.E.; Sgt. Robert Woodward | Terrorism & Energy Dissipating Systems; Spanning More than a River |
| 2002 | Linda N. Allen; Col. Douglas D. Gransberg; Keith R. Molenaar; Diana L. Pletz | Partnering D-B Contracts; Recent Graduates: On the Job |
| 2001 | Larry Woscyna; Lt. Scott Washburn | Kissimmee River Restoration; Old Light Station Sheds New Light |
| 2000 | Dana Finney; Lt. David J. Palazzetti, USCG | Smart Sensors at West Point; Maine Lights Program: Saving by Divestiture |
| 1999 | John E. Peters; Lt. John P. Slaughter, USCG | New in Naples; Disasters and the Coast Guard |
| 1998 | Lt. Cmdr. John W. Korka; Maj. Daniel J. Worth | Seabees in Bosnia |
| 1997 | Capt. Mark L. Gillem; Maj. Donald F. Archibald; Stephen W. Hughes | Creating Communities Not Compounds; Operation Joint Endeavor: Environmental Lessons |
| 1996 | Maj. Peter Tabacchi; Dr. Paul F. Mlaker; Col. Bruce K. Howard; Paul Redding | Restoring Brcko Bridge; On-Target Remediation |
| 1995 | Dr. Mark E. Zappi; Capt. Micheal Bowen | Peroxone POPS Groundwater; What’s Wrong with Mitigation Banks? |
| 1994 | Capt. Palmer W. Roberts; Jennifer C. Metts | Normandy: The Naval Story; Environmental Cleanup for Base Closure |
| 1993 | Brig. Gen. Ralph V. Locurcio; Col. Frank R. Finch; Maj. Deborah L. Nykyforchyn; Mary L. Hughes | Piercing Winds Hit Hawaii; Aerospace Composites for Civil Engineers |
| 1992 | Gordon S. Crighton; Capt. John E. Buse | Europe’s Channel Tunnel; Engineer Warrior Day |
| 1991 | Dr. Benjamin W. Remondi; C. Ernest Edgar IV | Artificial Constellation: The Global Positioning System; 249th Engineers Storm the Desert |
| 1990 | 1st Lt. Mark E. Austin; Rear Adm. G. Brian Estes | A New Method of Runway Repair; Trident Base East-Completing the Construction Program |
| 1989 | Dr. Jacques S. Gansler; Lauren Kaslow | Changes in the Defense Engineering/Business Environment for the 1990s; The DASE Co-op Program |
| 1988* | Graham Turbiville; Capt. Michael J. Kaleda | Soviet Engineers in Afghanistan; Building a Home for the B-1 |
| 1987 | Dr. Alexander G. Tarics | Earthquake: Are We Ready? |
| 1986 | Dr. Paul E. Torgersen | The Health of Engineering Education |
| 1985 | George B. Korte, Jr. | CADD’s Impact on NE Firms |
| 1984 | Lt. Col. Andrew M. Perkins | Operation URGENT FURY; An Engineer’s View |
| 1983 | Dr. Jacques S. Gansler | Industrial Preparedness: National Security in the Nuclear Age |
| 1982 | Thomas H. Spencer | The NE’s Role in Mobilization |
| 1981 | Dr. Hungdah Chiu | A Rapprochement Between the Two Chinas? |
| 1980 | James G. Stanley | Energy for Today and Tomorrow |
| 1979 | Dr. Leland R. Johnson | 19th Century Engineering: The Davis Island Lock and Dam (Parts I & II) |
| 1978 | Richard P. Howell | Upgrading the Northeast Rail Corridor |
| 1977 | Harry E. Bovay | Global Resources Outlook |
| 1976 | Dr. Leland R. Johnson | Sword, Shovel, and Compass |
| 1975 | Brig. Gen. William Whipple, Jr. | Water Supply and Energy Production in the Northeast |
| 1974 | Brig. Gen. George A. Lincoln | Energy Security |
| 1973 | Dr. Leland R. Johnson | 19th Century Engineering |
| 1972 | Maj. Gen. Richard H. Groves | The AGNES Disaster |
| 1971 | Maj. William B. Willard, Jr. | The National Environmental Crisis-An Engineer’s View |
| 1970 | Lt. Cmdr. Robert D. Smart | Man in the Sea: An Ocean Engineering Resource |
| 1969 | Walter J. Tudor | Antarctic Wharf In the Ice |
| 1968 | Lt. Col. Maurice K. Kurtz, Jr. | Nuclear Excavation Research |
| 1967 | Brig. Gen. Harry G. Woodbury, Jr. | Shipway between the Oceans |
| 1966 | Lt. James C. Thomas | The Computer Story |
| 1965 | Kenneth R. Stunkel | A Chronical of Mapping |
| 1964 | Alfred R. Golze | California State Water Project |
| 1963 | Col. Richard L. Clutterbuck | Military Engineering as a Weapon in the Cold War |
| 1962 | Brig. Gen. William R. Woodward | Space Logistics from Earth to Mars |
| 1961 | Capt. Charles J. Merdinger | Bridges through the Ages |
| 1960 | Lt. Cmdr. J.C. LeDoux | Nuclear Power: Promise and Problems |
| 1959 | Capt. Fred E. Kravath | Nuclear Development in Continental Europe |
| 1958 | Lt. Gen. R.A. Wheeler | Clearing the Suez Canal |
| 1957 | Cmdr. Charles J. Merdinger | Canals through the Ages |
| 1956 | Prof. Frank R. Barnett | Cracking the Thought Barrier |
| 1955 | Lt. Gen. Leslie R. Groves | Educating America for the Atomic Age |
| 1954 | Brig. Gen. John R. Hardin | The Mississippi-Atchafalaya Diversion Problem |
| 1953 | Cmdr. Palmer W. Roberts | Cold Weather Engineering |
| 1952 | Cmdr. Charles J. Merdinger | Roads through the Ages and Civil Engineering through the Ages |
| 1951 | Lt. Col. Robert R. Ellis | The Confederate Corps of Engineers |
| 1950 | Lt. Col. David B. Parker | Engineers in Atomic Offense And Defense |
| 1949 | Lt. Col. Stanley W. Dziuban | Artificial Flooding in Military Operations |
| 1948 | Dr. Roger Shaw | Adam to Atom |
| 1947 | Brig. Gen. Samuel D. Sturgis, Jr. | Engineer Operations in the Leyte Campaign |
| 1946 | Maj. Philip G. Krueger | Three Articles on Operation Crossroads |
| 1945 | Maj. Gen. Cecil R. Moore | Engineer Supply in the Continental Invasion |
| 1944 | Lt. Col. Walter C. Carey | Soil Engineering Practices for Military Engineers |
| 1943 | Maj. Gen. Julian L Schley | Policy of Preparedness |
| 1942 | Lt. Col. Shelby A. McMillion | Strategic Route to Alaska |
| 1941 | Lt. Col. Paul W. Thompson | Engineers in Battle |
| 1940 | Capt. Alfred D. Starbird | Strategic Canals |
| 1939 | Col. R.T. Ward | Engineers in the First Army Maneuvers at Plattsburg |
| 1938 | Maj. G.A. Roush | Strategic & Critical Minerals |
| 1937 | Maj. Elbridge Colby | John Churchill, Duke of Marlborough |
| 1936 | Maj. B.T. Reynolds | Italy, Ethiopia, and World Affairs |
| 1935 | Verne G. Sanders | Survey Map Control for Los Angeles |
| 1934 | Col. W. G. Caples | Transportation |
| 1933 | Col. Thomas H. Jackson | Leadership and Organization |
| 1932 | Col. E.G. Paules | With the Military Mission to Italy |
* Second medal authorized in 1988 for young members.